I would like to add a data point;
I recently bought Ed Ulrich's T-18, N883FF.
Ed hadn't flown it in 9 years. It had about 22 gallons of Mogas in it.
The last time he flew it, he secured every switch and the fuel valve. Maybe he knew it was his last flight.
I bought the plane thru his daughter, so I didn't get to meet him, nor pick up any pointers.
I did get a good stack of binders with useful info and about 100 News Letters.
But back to the fuel: it smelled bad, but I'm cheap. So I used the boost pump to decant it into a gas can, and promptly poured it into my nearly empty 1989 Chevy 3/4t pickup truck. This is the base line V-6 model.
It ran poorly, but OK on the flat. Come a hill, it would knock pitilessly, and lost power alarmingly. That 22 gallons seemed to last forever. I didn't dare step down on the gas more that just the smallest amount or it would ping and rattle. Probably got the best gas mileage I ever got.
I worried that the engine was permanently damaged, but finally when it was gone and some average gas was put in, it ran good again.
In an Aircraft it would have been a disaster.
I had to mop the tank out from sediment, including blobs of Fuel Lube which were under the filler cap. I'm not in favor of using Fuel Lube on cap seals any more after seeing the residual blobs in the bottom of the tank. That wouldn't do at all in the tank valve, or on the screen.
So if the fuel smells bad, I wouldn't use it. Maybe 6 months, I'd be worried at a year. Nine Years is redickulous! But it makes a good story.